The Best James Martin Sticky Toffee Pudding You’ll Ever Make

Introduction to James Martin Sticky Toffee Pudding

Now, here’s the thing: I’m really smitten with sticky toffee pudding. Like, seriously obsessed. It all started when I was about eight, standing in my grandma’s tiny kitchen watching her pull this golden, gooey masterpiece out of her ancient oven. You might forget your own name just from the smell.

I’ve been on a mission ever since to recreate that exact feeling, and let me tell you, I’ve made some absolute disasters along the way. But then I discovered James Martin’s version, and honestly? Game changer. This isn’t just any sticky toffee pudding – this is THE sticky toffee pudding that’ll make you question every other dessert you’ve ever eaten.

Why James Martin Sticky Toffee Pudding Became My Go-To

Look, I’ve tried probably twenty different versions of this pudding. Some were too heavy, some too sweet, and one memorable disaster that I’m pretty sure could’ve been used as building material. But this James Martin sticky toffee pudding? It’s like he read my mind.

The sponge is ridiculously light – none of that dense, sit-in-your-stomach-like-a-brick nonsense. And the sauce? Oh my god, the sauce. It’s thick enough to coat your spoon but not so thick it feels like you’re eating toffee cement. Plus, there’s this sneaky little trick with coffee that James uses – just a splash, mind you – that makes the whole thing taste more… well, more like itself, if that makes sense.

Print

A Bit of James Martin Sticky Toffee Pudding (Because I’m a Nerd Like That)

So apparently, there’s this whole debate about where sticky toffee pudding actually comes from. Two hotels are basically having a polite British argument about who invented it first – one up in the Lake District and another in Scotland. Most people seem to think it was the Sharrow Bay Hotel guys who nailed it in the 1960s.

What I love is that this whole thing started because people were trying to make something delicious with whatever they had during rationing. Dates were easier to get than sugar, and they figured out that if you mash them up properly, they make everything taste amazing. It’s like our grandparents accidentally invented heaven in a baking dish.

Let’s Talk Ingredients (And Why They Matter)

Right, so here’s what you actually need for this James Martin sticky toffee pudding. I’m not going to lie to you – there are no weird substitutions here. You need the real stuff.

For the sponge:

• 55g/2oz butter, plus extra for greasing
• 170g/6oz demerara sugar
• 1 tbsp golden syrup
• 2 free-range eggs
• 2 tbsp black treacle
• 200g/7oz self-raising flour, plus extra for flouring
• 200g/7oz pitted dates
• 290ml/10fl oz boiling water
• 1 tsp bicarbonate of soda
• ½ tsp vanilla extract

For the sauce that’ll change your life:

• 110ml/4fl oz double cream
• 55g/2oz butter, diced
• 55g/2oz dark muscovado sugar
• 2 tbsp black treacle
• 1 tbsp golden syrup
• vanilla ice cream, to serve

How to Actually Make It (Without Burning Your Kitchen Down)

Alright, here’s where it gets interesting. First, you chuck your dates in a pan with about 300ml of water and let them bubble away until they’re properly soft. After that, you blitz them up. I use my food processor, but if you’re feeling especially motivated, you could definitely mash them with a fork.

Here’s the magic bit – stir in a teaspoon of bicarbonate of soda and watch it go mental. It fizzes up like a science experiment, and that’s exactly what creates that perfect fluffy texture.

While that’s cooling down, cream your butter and sugar until it looks like something you’d actually want to eat. Then gradually add your beaten eggs (with a teaspoon of vanilla if you’ve got it), and gently fold in the flour. The key word here is “gently” – if you attack it like you’re kneading bread, you’ll end up with something that could double as a doorstop.

Mix in your date mixture, pour it into a greased dish, and bake at 200°C for about 40 minutes. You’ll know it’s done when a skewer comes out with just a few moist crumbs – we want sticky, not dry.

The Sauce (AKA Liquid Gold)

Make the sauce while the pudding bakes. Melt the butter and sugar together slowly – and I mean slowly. Then, until it’s glossy and beautiful, whisk in the cream. The trick is to not rush this bit. I learned that the hard way when I ended up with what looked like sweet scrambled eggs.

My Hard-Learned Tips for James Martin Sticky Toffee Pudding Success

After many (many) attempts, here’s what I’ve figured out:

Temperature is everything. Your butter needs to be properly soft, your syrup slightly warm, and your date mixture just cooled enough that it won’t scramble your eggs when you mix it in.

Don’t overmix. I cannot stress this enough. Once you add the flour, you’re just bringing it together, not trying to build muscle.

The sauce can be reheated. This is a game-changer for dinner parties. Make it ahead, then just warm it through gently.

Serve it properly warm. Not nuclear hot, not lukewarm – that perfect temperature where the sauce melts into the sponge but doesn’t make your ice cream disappear instantly.

Ways to Make It Your Own

Here’s where you can get creative with this James Martin sticky toffee pudding. I sometimes throw in some chopped pecans or walnuts for crunch. My mate Sarah adds a splash of rum to her sauce, which is honestly brilliant if you’re feeling fancy.

If you want to make it ahead (because you’re smarter than me and actually plan things), the sponge keeps really well. When you’re ready to serve, simply wrap it up and gently reheat it.

Why This Recipe Actually Works

The thing about this particular version is that it’s forgiving. I’ve made it when I was completely distracted by Netflix, and it still turned out gorgeous. Simply said, the metrics make sense when combined.

Plus, it freezes beautifully. I always make extra portions now because future-me is always grateful when I find a wrapped slice in the freezer on a random Tuesday.

Serving It Right

This is crucial – you need good vanilla ice cream. Not the cheap stuff that tastes like frozen milk, but proper vanilla ice cream that’ll complement that warm, sticky sauce. The contrast between hot and cold, sweet and slightly bitter from the dates, is what makes this dessert so ridiculously good.

I like to serve it in warmed bowls if I remember, and always with way more sauce than seems reasonable. There’s no such thing as too much sauce with sticky toffee pudding.

The Bottom Line

My go-to dessert is this James Martin sticky toffee pudding. It’s the thing people ask me to bring to dinner parties, and honestly, I’m not even slightly annoyed about it. There’s something properly satisfying about watching people’s faces when they take that first bite.

It is the epitome of comfort food—the kind of pudding that gives you hope that even after the worst day of your life, everything will be alright. And isn’t that exactly what good food should do?

Frequently Asked Questions About James Martin Sticky Toffee Pudding

Conclusion

All in all, this James Martin Stick Toffee Pudding recipe is one of my favourite desserts. My kids fell in love with this yummy treat. If you are more interested in more James Martin Recipes, check his category for more content.